Snack, beverage & the convenience channelNew York

Not Nutter Butter Or Chips Ahoy: These Are The Best Peanut Butter Cookies In Stores

Our writer tested seven grocery-store peanut butter cookies to find the best ones.

Rona Schwartz · Sep 12, 2026, 12:00 AM · Via Tasting Table

Rona Schwartz — Our writer tested seven grocery-store peanut butter cookies to find the best ones.

For buyers, the question is the facing, the pack, and whether the SKU earns cooler or dry-grocery space.

This file is based on reporting by Tasting Table. It is not a reprint, and it does not send the reader to another title.